22. 8. 2005
RSS backend
PDA verze
Čtěte Britské listy speciálně upravené pro vaše mobilní telefony a PDA
Reklama
Reklama
Celé vydání
Archiv vydání
Původní archiv

Autoři

Vzkaz redakci

OSBL
Tiráž

Britské listy

http://www.blisty.cz/
ISSN 1213-1792

Šéfredaktor:

Jan Čulík

Redaktor:

Karel Dolejší

Správa:

Michal Panoch, Jan Panoch

Grafický návrh:

Štěpán Kotrba

ISSN 1213-1792
deník o všem, o čem se v České republice příliš nemluví
22. 8. 2005

Mapping the limits of democracy

Did the media's fascination with the police action against the unofficial technoparty in Mlýnec last for so many days only because the summer silly season was in full swing and there was nothing else to write about?

I don't think so. It is important to look back and reassess what happened.

The events at Mlýnec have become an overarching metaphor for the current situation in the Czech Republic, symptomatic of a number of uncertainties and problems that are intensely felt by Czechs today. The technoparty has become an instrument that Czechs are using to try to map out the limits of democracy, freedom, tolerance, political manipulation, the rights of minorities, and law and order.

Legal experts from the Ministry of Interior have now come up with a draft law entitled "On the conditions of organizing some gatherings," the purpose of which is, apparently, to outlaw events like CzechTek. What seems to be bothering the experts at the Interior Ministry is the spontaneity and the non-hierarchical structure of these events. In typical Central European fashion, they are trying to overwhelm such spontaneous events with bureaucratic procedure. The Czech authorities are thus signaling that they are not prepared to tolerate a certain subsection of today's youth culture. The bill's discriminatory nature is self-evident. It would appear that Czech democracy must still master the principle of compromise, of inclusiveness. It was communist practice to suppress certain sections of society as "antisocial." The progress of this bill through Parliament will tell us a lot about contemporary Czech society.

Looking back, if we consider what happened at CzechTek and during the subsequent public debate, there is little to be impressed with.

The organizers of CzechTek at Mlýnec rented a plot of land, and there was no legal reason for the police -- who acted unprofessionally, inefficiently and brutally -- to act.

The event was then grossly misused for political ends. It is true that most of the mainstream media in the Czech Republic have now decided to support the Civic Democratic Party (ODS) in the pre-election period: Journalists in some Czech periodicals have been told never to publish anything critical about anyone from ODS. A newspaper is, of course, fully entitled to support whichever party it wishes, as long as it publicly declares its support. But to claim impartiality while looking for dirt on only one party is manipulation. Some mainstream Czech media are now systematically diging for dirt on Prime Minister Jiří Paroubek -- and the CzechTek controversy has been a Godsend.

Having said that, Paroubek's reaction to the events at Mlýnec has been disgraceful. What is particularly worrying is that Paroubek has been using expressions that are strongly reminiscent of the Gustáv Husák neo-Stalinist "normalization" era of the 1970s and 1980s when the regime strongly persecuted the alternative music culture.

Of course, watching the hypocrisy of ODS politicians, including President Václav Klaus, is depressing as well. It was, in a way, funny to see Czech right-wingers defending the supporters of dance music against the police since we know full well that if the ODS were in power they would use the police to suppress CzechTek even more brutally. But one cannot come down on the side of the CzechTek ravers either, who declared, like true ideological zealots, that their "values" are much more important than a few nights of other people's sleep.

Originally published in Czech Business Weekly HERE

                 
Obsah vydání       22. 8. 2005
22. 8. 2005 Tak co máme proti tomu dělat? Jindřich  Kalous
22. 8. 2005 Amerika ve válce: Prezident Bush se neodváží požádat občany, aby šetřili benzin Miloš  Kaláb
22. 8. 2005 Policie věděla, že Brazilec není bombový atentátník
19. 8. 2005 Nepočítejte s tím, že vás Policie ČR ochrání před násilníky... Štefan  Švec
22. 8. 2005 Mapping the limits of democracy Jan  Čulík
22. 8. 2005 Silnice jsou rozbité, úřední šiml řehtá, ale my vám přejeme příjemný den
22. 8. 2005 Poslanci potřebují na tramvaj Bohumil  Kartous
22. 8. 2005 Nešetřit si odvahu na lepší časy Petr  Pospíchal
22. 8. 2005 O odvážných Polácích, flegmatických Češích a neutrálních Brazilcích Fabiano  Golgo
22. 8. 2005 Nesmíme propadat mýtům Jan  Čulík
22. 8. 2005 O konečníku Alex  Koenigsmark
22. 8. 2005 Rakouskem obchází strašidlo nezaměstnanosti Richard  Seemann
22. 8. 2005 Odraz památky 21. srpna 1968 v činech Zdeněk  Jemelík
22. 8. 2005 Pro(ti)kuřácký zákon je na světě Josef  Provazník
22. 8. 2005 Normobčan 1.0 beta Tomáš  Gawron
22. 8. 2005 Komu patří internetové stránky Hospodářských novin Štěpán  Kotrba
22. 8. 2005 ĆT2: Tekno je mý všekno
22. 8. 2005 Teknival uprostřed metropole? Štěpán  Kotrba
21. 8. 2005 Podivné datum Petr  Wagner
21. 8. 2005 Happy birthday, pane premiére Štěpán  Kotrba
22. 8. 2005 Dnešní oběti v Jugoslávii Miroslav  Polreich
19. 8. 2005 Paroubek se rozhoduje mezi Siemensem a Kapschem Štěpán  Kotrba
19. 8. 2005 Neobčané v Evropské unii Oskar  Krejčí
18. 8. 2005 Constantin Plesky: "Strašně mě to mrzí..." Martin "Juki" Jyrkinen
19. 8. 2005 O dodržování pravidel podruhé -- a naposledy Milan  Černý
19. 8. 2005 Hospodaření OSBL za červenec 2005
22. 11. 2003 Adresy redakce

DIY, tekno a CzechTek RSS 2.0      Historie >
22. 8. 2005 Normobčan 1.0 beta Tomáš  Gawron
22. 8. 2005 Mapping the limits of democracy Jan  Čulík
21. 8. 2005 Happy birthday, pane premiére Štěpán  Kotrba
19. 8. 2005 Potřebujeme právní stát - ČR jím není   
19. 8. 2005 Kde doopravdy končí svoboda Ivo  Železný
19. 8. 2005 Kdo se měl stát ministrem kultury? Václav Šroub Ondřej  Slačálek
19. 8. 2005 Skutečný komunismus... a skutečný antikomunismus Ondřej  Slačálek
19. 8. 2005 O dodržování pravidel podruhé -- a naposledy Milan  Černý
19. 8. 2005 CzechTek 2005 -- malá záminka pro vážné důsledky Miroslav  Polreich
19. 8. 2005 US Rave Act -- aneb zákon proti technoparty po americku Bushka  Bryndová
18. 8. 2005 Vláda si přeje Štěpán  Kotrba
18. 8. 2005 LexTek Ondřej  Slačálek
18. 8. 2005 Pendrekový zákon Made in Bublan: Důvodová zpráva   
18. 8. 2005 Constantin Plesky: "Strašně mě to mrzí..." Martin "Juki" Jyrkinen
18. 8. 2005 Triky Cyrila Svobody proti komunistům: zneužití státních peněz Štěpán  Kotrba

Czech Politics: Jan Čulík's comment in Czech Business Weekly RSS 2.0      Historie >
22. 8. 2005 Mapping the limits of democracy Jan  Čulík
1. 8. 2005 Media must not give to stereotypes Jan  Čulík
18. 7. 2005 Media mistakes may just be growing pains Jan  Čulík
20. 6. 2005 The unexamined life is not worth watching Jan  Čulík
9. 5. 2005 Capitalist lapses, Communist lures Jan  Čulík
25. 4. 2005 Secretive politicians vanquish a media foe Jan  Čulík
4. 4. 2005 The democratic deficit in Czech politics Jan  Čulík
21. 3. 2005 Free speech is ours, but don't dare use it Jan  Čulík
28. 2. 2005 Poor education leads to workplace problems Jan  Čulík
21. 2. 2005 Grossgate revisited:the conspiracy theory Jan  Čulík
7. 2. 2005 Why I don't trust some newspapers Jan  Čulík
24. 1. 2005 The Greatest Czech? Jan  Čulík
10. 1. 2005 Compassion begins at the border Jan  Čulík
13. 12. 2004 Is Czech education failing the young? Jan  Čulík
6. 12. 2004 Is political satire now out of bounds? Jan  Čulík