17. 5. 2006
RSS backend
PDA verze
Čtěte Britské listy speciálně upravené pro vaše mobilní telefony a PDA
Reklama
Reklama
Celé vydání
Archiv vydání
Původní archiv

Autoři

Vzkaz redakci

OSBL
Tiráž

Britské listy

http://www.blisty.cz/
ISSN 1213-1792

Šéfredaktor:

Jan Čulík

Redaktor:

Karel Dolejší

Správa:

Michal Panoch, Jan Panoch

Grafický návrh:

Štěpán Kotrba

ISSN 1213-1792
deník o všem, o čem se v České republice příliš nemluví
17. 5. 2006

Political thuggery and strong women

Much has been written in the Czech media over the past weeks about the two recent instances of thuggery; communist MP Jiří Dolejš's beating in a metro station and the Green Party election candidate Kateřina Jacques's arrest and rough treatment by the Prague police while at a counter demonstration to a neo-Nazi march.

Often, commentators point to these two incidents as a sign of brutalization in contemporary Czech politics.

Published in Czech Business Weekly HERE

But there's another aspect to the assaults worth examining.

Whenever there is total media saturation of an event, it's extremely interesting to watch the public's reaction. In these instances that reaction, as manifested on various Internet fora or in the voluminous readers' mail to the Internet journal Britské listy, has been quite remarkable. While not a fully representative cross-section of Czech society, the responses have been so consistent that I feel they do say something quite worrying about the values of the nation's more vociferous members.

In the Dolejš instance, the vox populi seemed to coincide to a large degree with the view of the Czech right-wing press. The media, fearing a rise in the popularity of the communists (KSČM) noted that Dolejš had been roughed up, and quickly started an intensive counter-campaign, basically arguing that we shouldn't feel sorry for him because Stalin was a murderer thus unashamedly linking the worst excesses of totalitarian communist rule with this moderate MP.

It would appear that the public on the whole agreed with this line of reasoning. Since in the Czech Republic no one seems to trust anyone, there has also been a lot of rather "gothic" conspiracy theories: According to numerous correspondents, both Dolejš and Jacques had actually "organized" the assaults on themselves in order to manipulate the public to vote for them.

The opposition line

But there was something extra in the popular reactions to the Jacques incident, something of much concern. Here, the readers' voices were, on the whole, in opposition to the line taken by the Czech media.

Two factors seem to have coincided in this instance. In the first, many people have said that Kateřina Jacques "had it coming" because she had "defied the police" and one must "obey the orders of a police officer no matter what." These correspondents seemed to be unmoved by the fact that the reaction of the police was excessive and unprofessional, and prone to siding with the police whatever the circumstances. Is this evidence that many Czechs would actually prefer a return to authoritarian rule?

But the other type of reaction to the Jacques case has been even more worrying. Many members of the general public seem to have a problem with the simple fact that Jacques is a woman, that she is a politician and that she acts assertively in public. "Why all this fuss about a hysterical bitch?" wrote a great many in the chat rooms. "How dare she appear in public and take her children with her? If she was my wife, she would get a right thrashing on getting back home," opined one enlightened reader.

The position of women in Czech society is extremely difficult, as was pointed out by several women in a recent Britské listy debate. As a man, you're allowed to be assertive, they wrote, while an assertive woman is automatically labeled a "hysterical bitch." Although the men soundly rejected this summation, the public Jacques incident seems to confirm that these women are unfortunately accurate.

Jan Čulík is the editor in chief of Britské listy, www.blisty.cz. He also teaches Czech studies at the University of Glasgow, Scotland.

                 
Obsah vydání       17. 5. 2006
17. 5. 2006 Vysokoškolská stávka: Je to jako sledování automobilové havárie ve zpomaleném filmu
17. 5. 2006 Jak vyhrát volby Oskar  Krejčí
17. 5. 2006 Hledání vlastních zájmů Oskar  Krejčí
17. 5. 2006 ČRo: Svoboda sprostořekosti a odpovědnost Štěpán  Kotrba
17. 5. 2006 Čulíkova proč.... Ladislav  Žák
17. 5. 2006 Hospodský sonet Václav  Daněk
16. 5. 2006 Pentagon donucen zveřejnit videozáznam z 11. září
17. 5. 2006 Ruský medvěd je zpátky -- a tentokrát je na plyn
17. 5. 2006 Bohumil Doležal, extremismus a petice Tomáš  Pečený
17. 5. 2006 Zelení: Kam jsi to vlezl? Ven ! Štěpán  Kotrba
17. 5. 2006 Květnová nostalgie Pavel  Kopecký
17. 5. 2006 Závažné selhání protijaderného propagandisty Ivan  Brezina
17. 5. 2006 Opravdu parodie
16. 5. 2006 Na východní frontě klid...?! Ladislav  Žák
16. 5. 2006 Jeden z vynálezců internetu bude přednášet v Glasgow
17. 5. 2006 Truncheons and other pre-electoral tools Irena  Ryšánková
17. 5. 2006 Political thuggery and strong women Jan  Čulík
16. 5. 2006 Salon kritického myšlení, Litoměřice
16. 5. 2006 Německo chce zvýšit pokuty pro piráty silnic Radek  Vogl
16. 5. 2006 "Kolaborant Palata" - Psovi psí smrt? Jan  Čulík
17. 5. 2006 Klaus, Edelmannová a Palata
16. 5. 2006 "Být šťastný" jako slogan naší doby
16. 5. 2006 Domácí učitelé z třetího světa vyučují americké studenty na dálku
16. 5. 2006 Snižování daní nevede k zvýšení státních příjmů
16. 5. 2006 Maturity z logického a systémového myšlení Miroslav  Prokeš
16. 5. 2006 Komunismus a genocida Milan  Černý
16. 5. 2006 Racionální volič a labilní respondent Jan  Punčochář
16. 5. 2006 Zahraničně-politická témata v českých volbách 2006 Jiří  Pehe
15. 5. 2006 Českému Novákovi primitivní hospodské kecy v rádiu nevadí Jan  Čulík
15. 5. 2006 Dobré zprávy převažují Jiří  Pehe
6. 5. 2006 Hospodaření OSBL za duben 2006
22. 11. 2003 Adresy redakce